';

Twitter Dumps LinkedIn, Millions Rejoice

I joined LinkedIn in May 2006, user No. 5,796,753.

In the early days, before I was on Facebook (which hadn’t even opened to the general public yet), when Twitter was still Twttr, I used LinkedIn to reconnect to former work colleagues around the country, having hopped from state to state as a journalist over two decades.

In December 2008, when I was laid off from my newspaper job, it became an indispensable tool. Jobs came to me through LinkedIn, as I answered questions and commented in groups. I met new people and had great conversations.

Then, one day, LinkedIn started allowing people to import their Twitter accounts. There were two ways of doing it: You could import all tweets, or you could set up Selective Tweets, just like you could on Facebook. Just adding #in to the end of any Tweet would allow it to show up on your LinkedIn status.

Having to take that extra step, however, proved too difficult for most, and many people went the lazy route, importing their entire Twitter streams to LinkedIn.

Now, when you’d go to the pre-eminent business social network, you’d be greeted with a never-ending, constantly updating stream of Tweets, most of which had nothing to do with anything you’d come to LinkedIn to read about.

Foursquare updates. GetGlue check-ins. Replies of “lol” and “Thanks!” and emoticons. Comments that were borderline appropriate on Twitter, but completely out of place on LinkedIn.

People began complaining about LinkedIn, and how they got nothing out of it. “Why does anyone go there?” People would ask. If they hadn’t found the platform useful before the influx of Tweets, it was easy to see how they’d have trouble getting into it if they visited it and were faced with the same stream of updates they saw everywhere else (my diatribe against automatically connecting Twitter and Facebook is for another day).

I kept using LinkedIn, still finding it a great place to connect with people in a professional context. The recent addition of curated (and active communities such as Connect: Professional Women’s Network, which is sponsored by Citi, ramped things up a bit.

I’d noticed that the number of times my profile had been viewed by other users had been slowly going up recently as I’d become more active in Questions again and LinkedIn had improved user experience.

Then, the other day, Twitter decided it didn’t get any value from LinkedIn. It revoked its API access, allowing LinkedIn status updates to be sent to Twitter, but not the other way around.

I’d tweeted entreaties over the years for people to disconnect the two accounts, and when I read the email from LinkedIn with the news, I didn’t care why it had happened, I was just ready to do a jig in celebration. I actually squealed with delight. True story.

Nothing prepared me, however, for what happened next.

I posted an update on my profile expressing my delight at the change. One comment came. Then another. Then another.

I was getting comments from person after person – most of whom I didn’t even know and wasn’t connected to. As of this posting, I have 93 likes and 18 comments (including my own). I don’t even remember the last time I had a half-dozen likes and more than one or two comments. And have rarely had that much interaction on my posts.

That activity says two things to me: Posting updates on LinkedIn is about to get a lot more valuable, because people will see them and maybe even click through. And I’m not the only one who’s thrilled about the change.

If Twitter changes its mind, we can only hope LinkedIn will say thanks, but no thanks.

Photo by SJ Photography via Flickr Creative Commons.

24 comments
catalystpart
catalystpart

Hi Amy,

 

nice blog post but as you already know it is not correct that you can't post all your tweets to your LinkedIn profile. The simple solution is to use this recipe http://ifttt.com/recipes/43031

 

I understand and respect your opinion about whether people should post all their tweets to their LinkedIn profile. I have a lot of people thanking me for posting my tweets to my LinkedIn profile. Many of them are people who don't tweet and this way they receive lots of great content according to them.As I mentioned on Twitter if some of my connections find it to disturbing then they have the option to disconnect from me. 

 

I guess you can't make everybody happy all the time. 

 

Congratulations on an excellent blog in general.

 

Jorgen

AmyVernon
AmyVernon moderator

 @catalystpart I'm familiar with IFTTT, as you indicate. I also wrote this the day that Twitter disconnected and people weren't using IFTTT recipes for it yet, and I was desperately hoping it would not be. As you can see from the comments here (and the comments I got on LinkedIn itself when I posted about it), a great number of people dislike it.

Perhaps you tweet only excellent content, but I still feel extremely strongly about this. Not every Tweet belongs on LinkedIn, and an excellent middle ground is to create an IFTTT recipe that does what Selective Tweets used to do - only posting tweets with #LI or #in at the end. I don't see how posting what +K a person gave someone or a faceplant .gif that someone posted to their Tumblr belongs on LinkedIn.

I did look at your Twitter stream, and while you are primarily posting good content, you posted 9 things in one minute about half an hour ago, according to Twitter. If we were connected on LinkedIn, I wouldn't be able to see anything that anyone else had posted if I went to LinkedIn at that time, because the entire feed would be your imported Tweets. That is not valuable to me.

You are correct, I have the option to disconnect with a person who does that. But I also think that people should use discretion in automation and cross-posting. Not all automation is bad. Not all cross-posting is bad. But blanket anything is - automating one's entire Twitter feed and cross-posting everything (and you are by NO means the only person who does this, and, as I noted, your Tweets contain more quality than many others I see) - to me, at worst, spammy and at best, lazy.

All that said, I truly appreciate your conversation and how polite you were about it - far too many people would not be. I know I can come across as rather strident and brusque, but I'm from New York, so I can't always help that. Just ask @dannybrown ;)

catalystpart
catalystpart

 @AmyVernon Hi Amy, we all have our pet peeves that we defend strongly so please don't worry about coming across strident and/or brusque. I 'read' your frustration and I was quite OK with your tone :)While I appreciate that you have many positive comments here and on LinkedIn about the LinkedIn and Twitter divorce it does not necessarily represent the majority. I have never had a complaint from anybody I'm connected with on LinkedIn but only positive feedback so it's difficult for me to justify a change.As I mentioned earlier I appreciate and respect your opinion and will take it into consideration but please don't hold your breath :)

 

Jorgen

 

ps. I guess we'll never connect on LinkedIn :(

Jeane M.
Jeane M.

Wow, very well said. I love how LinkedIn helps me network with my colleagues but as you said, unnecessary infos really came flooding in all with no account on what I really need from page. So its likely cheers for the new changes.  Jeane M. http://www.arcanys.com

kstaxman
kstaxman like.author.displayName 1 Like

Yes I agree much of what works as a Tweet and the very nature of what Tweeting is all about just doesn't work on sites like LinkedIn and I've often wondered at the fact so many would chose to post all their Tweets to LinkedIn (or FaceBook for that matter). It does nothing but clutter up and confuse sites like LinkedIn when they allow users to openly follow or have posted a Twitter account. If people want Twitter it's easy enough to open an account and use it as it was intended.  Anyway lets hope that FaceBook does the same thing as it's as bad or worse on FaceBook to see all a person's tweets as it is on LinkedIn. In the end it comes down to users who try to fill their accounts with something all the time without really working at it. While you can do that it never really results in good posts only massive numbers of posts that make little or no sense. So hats off to Twitter for realizing that neither Linkedin nor Twitter gain from such activity and postings.

AmyVernon
AmyVernon moderator

 @kstaxman Absolutely. :) It bothers me a bit less on Facebook (but still plenty anyhow), because the app itself can be blocked from sight if you want, and at least they're not quite as inappropriate on FB. But I wouldn't be sad if that happened, either.

ValDur
ValDur like.author.displayName 1 Like

Great post Amy, I'm on the same page! In my mind, there should be a test you need to pass before allowing you to link your multiple accounts. Linkedin will surely benefit from being disconnected from Twitter!

AmyVernon
AmyVernon moderator

 @ValDur Thank you, Val! I love the idea of a test. Of course, given that we don't make people pass tests to have children, this is unlikely to happen. ;)

mzayfert
mzayfert like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

Always great perspective.  I never could understand why people were posting all twitter posts on linkedin.  Good move is right.

 

AmyVernon
AmyVernon moderator

 @mzayfert Well, Marilyn, I believe that people believed they were doing the right thing. But they were just adding noise to the signal.

AdamBritten
AdamBritten like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

"Posting updates on LinkedIn is about to get a lot more valuable" - You hit the nail on the head, here. Personally I completely ignore my LinkedIn news feed because it's turned into a repeat run of my Twitter news feed. Now that it'll be a lot cleaner, I'll be paying much more attention.

 

I am very happy with this move.

MorberMarketing
MorberMarketing like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

Amy V hits it out of the ballpark yet again! I feel like LinkedIn took a shower.....if you know what I mean. :)

 

iancleary
iancleary like.author.displayName 1 Like

Hey Amy,  I am delighted with this also.  I hated the amount of tweets that made no sense to be in LinkedIn.  It's a good day for all of us!  I assumed that LinkedIn realised it wasn't useful and removed it!!! Ian

AmyVernon
AmyVernon moderator

 @ianmcleary My first thought was that LI had come to its senses. I was a tad disappointed when I realized it was at Twitter's behest, but still thrilled with the end result. I believe LinkedIn is getting the word that this is a good thing and is none to disappointed.

cynthiaschames
cynthiaschames like.author.displayName 1 Like

 @AmyVernon EXACTLY!  I'm still on Cloud 9 today...have been peeking at my lovely, new, clean LinkedIn front page all day. 

AmyVernon
AmyVernon moderator

 @kstaxman  @cynthiaschames I know! I'm not sad about the IFTTT shutdown for that reason. But actually they were shut down because they'd been violating the Twitter API for months, apparently, not because of the new restrictions.

 

I used to tweet out once every six months and tell people that they killed a puppy each time they sent a tweet automatically to LinkedIn. One or two folks would always unlink them, and I felt as if I'd made a HUGE breakthrough in that. :)

kstaxman
kstaxman

 @AmyVernon  @cynthiaschames 

No Amy you weren't the only one who hated Twitter on Linkedin but most of us who didn't like it knew that it didn't  do any good to say anything.

 

The kind of person who would link all their Tweets to their Linkedin account would fail to see anything wrong with doing it that way. It seems there are many people that just love noisy timelines.

 

A good example is all the #FF tagged tweets you find on a Friday on Twitter. They are so numerous as to make them less than worthless. But they proliferate none the less. However to say anything to such posters is to raise their ire with no results so the it leaves one of two choices.. drop the poster or live with the noise.

 

Luckily we don't have to make those choices on Linkedin anymore. And now with Twitter basically shutting down IFTTT Linkedin is again totally free of noisy Twitter feeds again.